When someone asks me “what bands do you like?”, I rack off the list, the Arctic Monkeys have never made that bracket. That same person asks me “why they’re not included”. This reply always takes an absolute age to explain, so I’m officially going to publish it in writing so I won’t have to waste a good 10 minutes of someones valuable time to explain the reasons.
So. Enjoy.
Theres a fine line between naturally being good at something and trying too hard to be good at the same thing. There’s also a make up of specific attributes that really make a band great.
These two areas are where the Arctic Monkeys fall short, in terms of actually being really good. Alex Turner has a very unqiue voice, which is really not a bad thing at all, if anything it helps a band capture their own identity, but when you (a band) really force and focus all your music on the lead singers vocal attributes, that’s where the problem lies.
It’s just not necessary.
The rather irritating aspect of this specific problem is that when they released their first few songs and their first album, they just made a lot of noise and didn’t feel obligated to satisfy anyone.
It was actually not bad, their early stuff, I didn’t mind it just for the fact that they made a lot of noise.
The album AM is a prime example of how they’ve changed for the worse, in my opinion. Every song of this record demonstrates how obvious it is for a band to have a unique selling point and just tear it to shreds. (Im talking here about Turner’s vocals. Not the vocals themselves but the way he sings them. He really doesn’t need to go full Yorkshire all the time).
If you listen to it, the question you need to be asking is that “Can any other band do the same thing?” Or “Are the Arctic Monkeys actually unique?” The answer is Yes and No. Yes, any band could produce exactly the same material with a lead singer who hasn’t got such a Yorkshire accent. No because they actually don’t add anything new as a group and don’t really have a USP.
Listen to this:
How many “o’s” does Alex Turner have to really exaggerate before we understand what he’s saying? Its a slight irritant that has run throughout this group, especially for this album.
(The guitar rhythm is simple enough to create a good tune as well, it’s just wasted).
I think that took about 10 minutes.
Cheers.